09 July 2013

Yasiin Bey and Gitmo-Style Force-feeding

I just came across this video clip on the Guardian site.

I thought I should link to it. This is not because I want to make any moral points about Guantanamo Bay. That would be so redundant. No one, save perhaps Tea Party aligned Congresspeople, can justify Gitmo. What they call "the worst of the worst" are mostly ordinary people who were victims of the "wrong place, wrong time" syndrome.
Today, 166 inmates remain. Three have been convicted, while a further 30 will face trial. Fifty or so are in a legal no-man's-land, deemed by the authorities too dangerous to release but against whom there is not enough evidence to prosecute. And then there are 86 who have been cleared for release, but who instead rot in a hell from which there is no escape.
The main reason why they cannot be released is that they know too much. And if, upon their release, they talk about the condition of their detention, they could shatter the doctrine of American exceptionalism.

The main reason I linked to it to find out if this was shown on North American TV. Somehow I doubt that Nightly News programs in the US had this clip in their carefully selected 22 minutes.

The other reason was to say, kudos to Dante Terrell Smith, a.k.a. Yasiin Bey a.k.a. Mos Def for providing a visual aid for what the US military calls "medical intervention."



Incidentally,
Forced-feeding in prisons has been outlawed since 1975 when the World Medical Association issued the Declaration of Tokyo, guidelines for physicians concerning torture and other cruel or degrading treatment in relation to detention. The declaration stipulates that: "Where a prisoner refuses nourishment and is considered by the physician as capable of forming an unimpaired and rational judgement concerning the consequences of such a voluntary refusal of nourishment, he or she shall not be fed artificially."

07 July 2013

About the US Role in Ousting Mursi (Morsi) in Egypt

A good friend of mine objected to to my recent post on Egypt. 

He felt that I was overstating the American influence over the Egyptian army. In his view, the US was caught off guard when the army refused to protect Mubarak almost two years ago and the events of the last couple of days were no different: he was convinced that the Egyptian army chief General al-Sisi decided to depose Muhamed Mursi, the Egyptian President with little or no interference from the US.

I wish that were true.

The reality is that the Egyptian army will not do much without getting prior authorization from the US.

In this instance, besides the two calls placed to al-Sisi (Martin Dempsey and Chuck Hagel) that I mentioned in my last post, American ambassador Anne Patterson tried to persuade the Brotherhood to make concessions in order to avoid a coup. So much so that the protesters got the impression that the US was working on behalf of Mursi.  But sadly for everyone concerned, it did not work.
Meanwhile, in Cairo, Egyptian protesters were infuriated that Ambassador Patterson met with Brotherhood Deputy Supreme Guide Khairat El Shater for three hours on the eve of the crisis. But the real problem was not the meeting, but that she was unable to persuade Shater and the Brotherhood to make the real concessions that might have prevented this crisis. 
Today, the New York Times provides a more detailed picture.
As President Mohamed Morsi huddled in his guard’s quarters during his last hours as Egypt’s first elected leader, he received a call from an Arab foreign minister with a final offer to end a standoff with the country’s top generals, senior advisers with the president said.
The foreign minister said he was acting as an emissary of Washington, the advisers said, and he asked if Mr. Morsi would accept the appointment of a new prime minister and cabinet, one that would take over all legislative powers and replace his chosen provincial governors. [my emphasis]
Mursi said no, partly because he was convinced that General al-Sisi was a devout Muslim who would never topple an Islamist President. Part of that trust goes back to the early phases of the Tahrir Square struggle where the army and the Brotherhood worked together to protect the anti-Mubarak uprising. (And that's according to the New York Times.)

Mursi's answer was relayed to the American ambassador.
His top foreign policy adviser, Essam el-Haddad, then left the room to call the United States ambassador, Anne W. Patterson, to say that Mr. Morsi refused. When he returned, he said he had spoken to Susan E. Rice, the national security adviser, and that the military takeover was about to begin, senior aides said. [my emphasis]
“Mother just told us that we will stop playing in one hour,” an aide texted an associate, playing on a sarcastic Egyptian expression for the country’s Western patron, “Mother America.”

The article also notes that prior to that point the Ambassador met repeatedly with Mursi's advisers.
Mr. Morsi’s advisers had meetings with Ms. Patterson and her deputy as well as a phone call with Ms. Rice, the national security adviser. Mr. Morsi’s advisers argued that ousting the president would be “a long term disaster” for Egypt and the Arab world because people would “lose faith in democracy.” They said it would set off an explosion in the streets that they could not control. 
And they argued that the United States was implicated: “Nobody who knows Egypt is going to believe a coup could go forward without a green light from the Americans.” [my emphasis]
At that point, despite Mursi's oblivious posture, some of his advisers must have felt that a coup was imminent.
At a meeting with General Sisi at 2 p.m. the next day, Mr. Morsi’s advisers said that they had their coalition’s blessing to accept the earlier concessions the general had suggested before the protest.
 But four hours later, the General informed them that the opposition rejected Mursi's last minute concessions.
Mr. Morsi’s team did not know who the general actually consulted and the young protest leaders and some other opposition leaders said they did not know either. But that night Mr. Morsi delivered a fiery address denouncing his opponents as traitorous conspirators. 
General Sisi later publicly cited the speech as a turning point in his decision to act.
In light of the previous negotiations, I read this last paragraph as the speech was the turning point not for the General but for the administration as they decided that Mursi was hopeless. That he would rather become a martyr than give in to these demands. And gave General Sisi the green light.

For the record, I think it was a stupid move that will backfire. They should have kept the pressure on and get him in a broad coalition.

At this point, no one can govern Egypt without the Islamists and certainly without the Brotherhood. Already Mohamed ElBaradei's appointment as Prime Minister was contested by the Salafist Party and immediately withdrawn by the acting President Adly Mansour. They may still go ahead with it but it is a strong sign.

Moreover, as I noted in my last post, I don't think Egypt's structural economic problems had anything to do with Mursi's mismanagement and they cannot be solved by a caretaker government.

I just hope that the US and the Egyptian army have a decent plan to insert the Islamists quickly into the political process.

One last thing: please, oh please, find a way to spell Arabic names in a uniform fashion. Mursi, Morsi, Morsy? Maybe it was Morissey?

Come on.

After decades of Kaddafi, Qaddafi, Qaddafy, Gaddafy, Western media ought to know better.

---------------
UPDATE

About 50 members of Muslim Brotherhood were killed when the army opened fire on protesters.

If they continue on this path, with every passing day, it will get harder to reintegrate Egyptian Islamists in to the political process.

And Egypt is not Algeria: it is no longer possible to suppress the Islamists violently. Sooner or later, they will have to be part of the political class.


04 July 2013

Hezbollah and Salafists Bringing Lebanon Into Syrian Conflict

Unless you are a very keen student of the Salafist movement in Lebanon, you've probably never heard of Sheikh Ahmad al-Assir. At least not until recently.

Assir is a Lebanese Salafist cleric who popped up out of nowhere at the beginning of the Syrian civil war. He quickly rose to prominence through his passionate sermons, sharply criticizing the Hezbollah, the Shiite paramilitary group widely feared and disliked by the Sunni community of Lebanon. He is well known for his over-the-top tactics like blocking the highway to Sidon in July 2012, ostensibly in a bid to stop the flow of arms to Hezbollah.

Despite the fact that his father was Sunni and his mother was a Shia, his sermons are designed to incite sectarian hatred:
He once delivered a sermon at his mosque while holding a toy rifle. He told his Salafist supporters that the rifle was made in Iran and releases an audio in Arabic saying "kill Aisha" — Aisha is one of the wives of Muslim Prophet Muhammad, and is a subject of historical dispute between Sunnis and Shiites. It later turned out that the toy had nothing to do with Iran or Assir’s claims. It is manufactured in China and says in English, "Kill the hostages."
Throughout his meteoric rise Assir emphasized two points. One was his hatred for the Syrian strongman Bashar al-Assad and he kept urging his followers to join the fight against him. The second was his hatred for the Hezbollah and he kept asking for the paramilitary organization to be disarmed and disbanded. As a corollary to that latter point, he was very critical of the Lebanese army as he believed (like many Sunnis in Lebanon) that they were in cahoots with the Hezbollah.  

Recently, with the Hezbollah joining the fight in Syria and helping Assad's army to retake a strategic city of Qusayr situated near the Lebanese border, Assir escalated his rhetoric against the Shiite paramilitary group. On 23 July, his followers attacked a Lebanese army check point near the southern city of Sidon and killed several officers and soldiers (reports range from 3 to 12).

In response to that, the army surrounded his compound and heavy fighting erupted. Initially, Assir followers suffered heavy casualties and it looked like the army was going to be able to overrun his headquarters. But according to the McClatchy News, fighters from the al-Nusra Front (a group linked to Al Qaeda and the most effective rebel force in Syria) came to his rescue. With the help of these battle-hardened Salafist soldiers, Assir and about 100 of his militants staged a breakout and escaped.
A Lebanese army intelligence official confirmed the presence of foreign fighters inside the compound, saying that an emotional and ill-advised reaction to the checkpoint attack by army officers on the scene led to the initially heavy army casualties. 
You might think that this is no big deal. Actually, it is.

First of all, it means that the al-Nusra Front is now expanding beyond Syria. As it is the most ruthless and successful armed group in Syria, its presence and growing influence in Lebanon and Iraq (surprisingly, against the wishes of Ayman al-Zawahiri) must be a source of worry for most regional actors.

Secondly, their presence in Sidon will be perceived as a response to the Hezbollah military campaign in Syria. It is a statement, as in, if you help Assad retake Qusayr we can come to your backyard and help Sunni groups against you. This is a very dangerous tit-for-tat game in a sharply divided country like Lebanon.

For its part, the Hezbollah already met the challenge and joined the Lebanese army to fight the remaining Salafists in Sidon. Predictably, this led to angry outbursts.
Sunni anger has intensified following reports that Hezbollah members were fighting alongside the Lebanese army during the Sidon clashes. The army has denied this was the case.
Despite the army's denials, some footage of Hezbollah soldiers with their yellow arm bands emerged. In fact, Hezbollah owned Al-Manar TV showed some soldiers taking away Sunni militants while shouting "Ya Zaynab" a popular Shiite battle cry, referring to the daughter of Ali, the first Imam for Shiites. The army's reaction was to issue a threat to anyone who reported that the Hezbollah was helping them.

In the meantime, as Sunni loyalists tried to reach the compound to show their support for Assir, they were blocked by the army. This led to days of violent protests in Sidon, Tripoli (Lebanon) and all over the country.

These protests highlight a significant problem in Lebanon: The army has been one of the few institutions that managed to remain above sectarian politics. But these incidents could change that very rapidly.
Yet since Hizbullah’s inclusion in Lebanon's government in 2008, the group’s influence on state institutions, including the army, has grown, feeding Sunni worries. Today many Sunnis accuse the army of cracking down disproportionately on Sunni militants, while Shia militias such as Hizbullah remain armed. Reports that Hizbullah fighters helped the army in Sidon did little to boost its neutral image. This anger and fear over a lack of representation, armed or otherwise, of the Sunni community helped Mr Assir build his following. Many see Mr Assir's rise as part of increased Sunni militancy in Lebanon, inspired in part by Syria’s co-religionist rebels, but also by a sense that no one else will defend their interests.
As I suggested, sectarian violence is a feature in Syria but it would definitely be a bug in Lebanon.

Finally, when collectively taken, these events point to a growing Shia-Sunni divide in the region. To be fair, Sunnis always considered the Shia kafir and the animosity between the two sects border on hatred. But in the current climate, it looks like Iran, Iraq and Syria are in perpetual struggle with Saudi Arabia, Qatar and the historic sword of Sunni Islam, Turkey.

Unless a rapid solution is found to the Syrian civil war and cool down sectarian hostilities, what I assumed to be an attempt to bring stability to the region might end up in a catastrophe.

Read more here: http://www.mcclatchydc.com/2013/06/25/194944/al-qaida-linked-nusra-front-rebels.html#.UdBKLW15cpD#storylink=cpy

03 July 2013

My Take on the Islamist - Army Confrontation in Egypt

You must have seen the breathless headlines about the dark future awaiting Egypt's beleaguered President  Mohammed Mursi.

Indeed, these last weeks have not been very good for the Muslim Brotherhood. Millions of people gathered in Cairo and around the country and held huge anti-Mursi rallies. They ransacked the Brotherhood's shiny new HQ, the Salafist al-Nour Party deserted the president and called for early elections, all non-Brotherhood members of the cabinet resigned and the army issued an ultimatum for a compromise power sharing solution to be found within 48 hours.

Most commentators seem to think that Mursi's days are numbered and he will either resign or be sacked by the army in the coming days.

As the resident contrarian I am not so sure.

Let me explain.

It is the Economy Stupid

The reason why these protests were so widespread and so successful has little to do with the creeping Islamisation of Egypt. That was already the case under Mubarak. And if you look at the electoral success of the Brotherhood and the Salafist Nour party, you can see that a majority of Egyptians do favor an overt Islamist system.

What did Mursi in is the state of the economy. Instead of giving it its top priority, he focused on either silly ideological measures, like dealing with skimpy swimwear and alcohol in resorts or expanding the Brotherhood's grip within the state apparatus like fast-tracking a dubious draft constitution and placing his office above courts.

As a result, within a year, the already fragile Egyptian economy was in ruins:
Tourism and investment have dried up, inflation is rampant and fuel supplies are running short, with power cuts lengthening in the summer heat and motorists spending hours fuelling cars. 
The cost of insuring government debt against default surged to record highs. Forward contracts indicated a significant fall for the pound against the dollar.
Along with economic mismanagement, Mursi and the Brotherhood failed to ensure the basic tenets of governance. Remember Hobbes' Leviathan and the deal people made to escape, their nasty, brutish and short lives?
I asked four middle-aged men, two taxi drivers and two accountants, sipping sweet tea and puffing tobacco through water pipes in a scruffy pavement café, whether they would prefer to have a man like former President Hosni Mubarak back in office.
They all said yes, as if it was the most obvious thing in the world. "It's because back then we were safe!" finished one of the accountants.
Given these serious economic mismanagement and governance errors, you might think that the army would be justified in intervening and sacking Mursi. The problem is that the army is in no position to fix the economy. If they take over, they own the problem.

In fact, an intervention might destabilize the country even further and wipe out all that is left of tourism revenues. After all, if the army removes the duly elected president, it is highly unlikely that the Brotherhood will stand idly by and accept this. The Brotherhood may be terrible at governing but they are very good at clandestine resistance work.

The army has another problem and that is to find a unified front capable of governing Egypt. If the opposition forces were united and had such a candidate, they would have been able to field him against Mursi. If you recall, the elections were between Mursi and Ahmed Shafik, a Mubarak-era air force general under Mubarak.

As for Muhammed ElBaradei, well, he might have been a decent administrator when he was running IAEA and he is liked by the Western powers but he has no constituency in Egypt and I doubt that he can be an effective president. Especially if the Brotherhood and the Salafists were to oppose his government. And they will.

Just as people turned against Mursi when faced with a terrible economy, they will turn against the army within six months.

So, I don't see why would the army get involved in a situation that has no good solution.

The Larger Picture

There is also the issue of the stability of the region. Removing Mursi and pushing the Brotherhood underground would negatively affect the Israeli - Palestinian peace process. It would also have serious implications on the Syrian civil war.

If you remember my starting point and the decisive role of the armies in Tunisian and Egyptian regime changes and the US plans to bring stability to the Middle East by solving the Palestinian and Kurdish problems, you might see why sacking Mursi would make no sense for the region.

The regime change was needed to force Israel to come to the table (and the army was there to ensure that the Brotherhood didn't do anything to jeopardize Israel's security). Bringing in another strongman like Mubarak would mean a return to status quo ante with all the false sense of security such an arrangement entailed for Israel.

It just makes no sense.

You might think that I attach too much importance to American influence in the region. Maybe. But once the military gave that 48 hour ultimatum, do you know what happened?
General Martin Dempsey, the top U.S. military officer, called the chief of staff of Egypt's armed forces on Monday morning, a U.S. defense official told Reuters, without providing details on the conversation. 
The call by Dempsey, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, to Egypt's Sedki Sobhi came the same day that Egypt's armed forces handed Islamist President Mohamed Mursi a virtual ultimatum to share power.
And do you know what happened after that call? The Egyptian army issued a clarification.
The Egyptian armed forces issued a statement on Monday denying that an earlier statement from its commander amounted to a military coup and said his aim was only to push politicians to reach consensus.
Denying any political ambitions for itself, the military said it was responding to the "pulse of the Egyptian street" in issuing an ultimatum to political leaders to unite after mass rallies on Sunday against President Mohamed Mursi.
I am writing this as people await anxiously the army's response as the deadline has come and passed.

I would be quite surprised if the army actually mounts a coup. If they do, that would mean that there are other variables that we don't know about.

But under normal circumstances, my guess would be that the army will stop short of sacking Mursi and with ask for the formation of a national unity government with decent representation for the opposition parties. Perhaps with al-Baradei as the Prime Minister and Mursi as President.

We'll see soon enough.
----------------------
Well so much for that. They actually did it.
----------------------
UPDATE:

Before the army announced its non-coup coup, apparently Chuck Hagel, the US Secretary of Defense called General Ahmed Fattah al-Sisi. No one knows what they talked about but my guess would be that Hagel tried to dissuade al-Sisi from intervening, as I am sure the US would have preferred a broad consensus coalition with the participation of the Brotherhood. And clearly he failed.

Obama's reaction was telling in many respects.
"We are deeply concerned by the decision of the Egyptian Armed Forces to remove President Morsi and suspend the Egyptian constitution.
I now call on the Egyptian military to move quickly and responsibly to return full authority back to a democratically elected civilian government as soon as possible through an inclusive and transparent process, and to avoid any arbitrary arrests of President Morsi and his supporters.
Given today's developments, I have also directed the relevant departments and agencies to review the implications under US law for our assistance to the Government of Egypt.
The voices of all those who have protested peacefully must be heard - including those who welcomed today's developments, and those who have supported President Morsi."
First, he notes that he is deeply concerned.

Second, he calls on the military to give power back to a civilian government. He is careful to say a democratically elected government instead of the democratically elected government.

Third, he avoids the word coup because that would force him to cut military aid to Egypt and remove his main leverage. But he still threatens them with a review.

Finally, he urges for the inclusion of Islamists in the new system, as he knows that no one can rule Egypt without their consent.

25 June 2013

What To Do About Your Digital Footprint and Online Security

There are two schools of thought on this.

One side says that if you have nothing to hide why worry about such things, let them sift through your data. The other side says that even if I have nothing to hide, if they have the ability to record all my exchanges, the day I disagree with them publicly, they can destroy me by divulging embarrassing details about me.

I am not going to tell you which side makes more sense, that is up to you. But I will suggest a couple of things in case you want to take some measures.

First the facts:

1) Assume that all your phone conversations and email exchanges are recorded and stored. The storage technology and database software are so advanced that this is really easy and fairly inexpensive to do. Most of the time, no one will every listen to what you said or read what you wrote. This is why they issue blanket denials with a straight face. But if they need to, they can.

2) All your Internet activities are stored in several company servers, especially Google. Your queries are analyzed and your digital footprint is saved to sell stuff to you later on. If you book a trip to Orlando, the next day, your favorite blog will have ads for Disney World just for you.

3) Your email is like sending a postcard. It is visible to everyone. Think twice before you send your neighbor your home alarm system code for them to water your plants.

4) When you download something through torrents, don't assume that you are invisible: your ISP can see everything you download. In many places you will get a warning letter and if you persist some Movie or Music Association will sue you for everything you have got.

My suggestions:

1) For Privacy

If you wish to avoid your activities and exchanges being recorded and stored, start by using a Virtual Private Network (VPN). A VPN is a protocol that takes your Internet traffic away from your ISP's servers and re-routes it through encrypted servers. In other words, it makes your Internet explorations invisible to snoopers and hackers.


Note that this does not mean anonymous: Google will still know that you booked an Orlando ticket but your activities will be invisible to other prying eyes.

How to choose a VPN system? Most are commercial companies, which means you have to pay for the service (there are free systems but they are much slower). A couple of pointers:

- Choose the one that has many servers around the world so that you can have different IP addresses. This will also enable you to watch country specific programs by providing you an IP address in that country.

- Test their performance before you sign up. There should be very little speed penalty for going through their servers (roughly 10 percent speed degradation is acceptable).

- If you want decent protection L2TP/IPsec is a better protocol than the more common PPTP.

- Finally, if you are very serious about government interference. select a service that does not maintain logs.

Click here for a review of top VPN service providers.

Besides VPN, you can also use the "private browsing" option in Firefox.

2) For Anonymity

VPN makes your Web surfing private but not anonymous.

If you want to render your activities both private and anonymous you need to go through something like Tor. Tor was designed for the US Navy but it is now open to the public and is free.

What it does is this:

Internet traffic is composed of small packets of data with an address header to indicate where they are supposed to go.

Tor removes the final address from the header and moves these packets through secure servers one at a time.

At every step the next server is randomly chosen and only its address is given.

This way, and each time the header is changed and a new address is given, which thwarts attempts to follow your traffic.

Keep in mind that Tor involves a serious speed degradation.

3. Nothing Is Really Erased

Nothing you do or write on the Internet ever disappears. Most Web sites are stored at the Wayback machine.

Even dead sites are backed up somewhere. For instance, within two days of Snowden's appearance people found out that when he was 18 he wrote silly stuff in a now defunct Web site.

All your tweets are stored and Twitter has a deal with Library of Congress to make them available online. Right now it is a slow system but eventually it will become a searchable database.

And despite what Facebook says, nothing is completely erased on their site. Consider a fake identity.

In any case, exercise caution when you make statements. Any of it can pop up somewhere when you least expect it.

4. Secure Email

If you want your email to be a bit more secure than Gmail (your email messages are routinely scanned by intelligent bots to find key words to sell you stuff) use Hushmail.

Another way of making your email more secure is to use encryption. While the system is fairly easy it involves sending your interlocutors a private key and a public key so it could get cumbersome for most people.

Here is a primer.

5. Disposable Addresses

When you sign up for a service, do not use your regular email address. They are sold to spammers and they are also used to track your movements on the Web.

You can either use a service like Yahoo to create a new address with a fake name and fake original email account (which is getting harder to do). Or you can use a service like 10 Minute Mail. This service gives an address for ten minutes or just long enough to sign up to a site and receive a confirmation link via email. Once you confirmed your existence to the site you want to register to, your email disappears forever. Good luck tracking you through that disposable address.

6. Never Use the Same Password Everywhere 

If you use the same password for your alumni Web site and your bank, the day that alumni site is hacked, those people will be able to get into your bank account as well.

A simple method of selecting and retaining your passwords would be this:

- Choose a specific book, determine a page and use s specific line in that page as your password for a site; use the the same line of the next page for another site and so on.

- Simply list those sites on a piece of paper in their proper order and put it in the book. If you selected page 20 and line three for the first one you will know what to do. The next one will be page 21 and line 3. And 22 and line 3.

- Even if someone were to find the list they would not know what to do with it without the page and line information.

7. Avoid Torrents If You Can

If you want to find specific files try Usenet. It is accessible through your email client (like Outlook or Thunderbird) but you will not find much unless you sign up for a paying service like GigaNews. They have a search engine (Mimo) and you can get a VPN (VyprVPN) for the price of a monthly subscription.

If you don't know what Usenet is, forget I mentioned it. You are better off by not knowing it.

And if after all that, you are still intercepted by the Big Brother, whatever you do, don't mention me.

24 June 2013

A Couple of Notes on Edward Snowden

The revelations by the NSA whistle-blower Edward Snowden did not surprise me. In fact, I was surprised that people were shocked to find out that all our communications were being monitored.

Let me say it without moving my lips: This has always been the case and it will always be the case.

This is nothing new. Have you heard of the ECHELON system?
ECHELON is a name used in global media and in popular culture to describe a signals intelligence (SIGINT) collection and analysis network operated on behalf of the five signatory states to the UKUSA Security Agreement (Australia, Canada, New Zealand, the United Kingdom, and the United States, referred to by a number of abbreviations, including AUSCANNZUKUS and Five Eyes). It has also been described as the only software system which controls the download and dissemination of the intercept of commercial satellite trunk communications. [my emphasis]
Read the last sentence one more time.

But during the last decade, most of the communication traffic was moved from satellites to fiber optics. So the first thing the Cheney Administration did after 9/11 was to design a program (with the Orwellian name Total Information Awareness or TIA) to gather data from telephone communications, email, social media, credit card receipts and all online transactions without warrants. Admiral Poindexter, the formerly convicted felon of the Iran-Contra scandal, was the point man for this brilliant idea.

When TIA was greeted with dismay, the Cheney Administration changed tack and had the NSA approach the Telcos in 2001 to get direct and secret access to the Internet backbone. This is known as the "NSA Warrantless Surveillance Program" and it was exposed by James Rosen and Eric Lichtblau of the New York Times in December 2005 (incidentally, they filed the story a year before but Bill Keller, the Editor of the liberal NY Times decided to sit on it until after the 2004 presidential elections).

Thanks to that story, we learned that there was a Room 641A in the AT&T floors of the SBC Communications Building in San Francisco and beam splitters installed in fiber optics trunks pushed all of Internet traffic through the computers in that room.

In other words, they had access to everything. But when the story broke, the NSA claimed that it was not listening in on any conversation between two American citizens. They had access but refrained from using it. And they never listened in on innocent parties. Some people might be naive enough to believe these assurances but they were not quite true. For instance, some whistle-blower revealed that NSA analysts were listening regular conversations between military personnel and their families:
Faulk says he and others in his section of the NSA facility at Fort Gordon routinely shared salacious or tantalizing phone calls that had been intercepted, alerting office mates to certain time codes of "cuts" that were available on each operator's computer.

"Hey, check this out," Faulk says he would be told, "there's good phone sex or there's some pillow talk, pull up this call, it's really funny, go check it out. It would be some colonel making pillow talk and we would say, 'Wow, this was crazy'," Faulk told ABC News. 
But American exceptionalism being what it is, people disregarded such stories and believed that the NSA folks would never, ever listen in on their fellow citizens.

Once the warrantless surveillance became public, the Cheney Administration pushed a new legislation through Congress (a bi-partisan effort) which exonerated the Telcos, retroactively justified the warrantless surveillance practice and gave the NSA the power to acquire large scale warrants from the secret FISA Court to monitor unspecified communications between unspecified parties.

Then they continued to record and data mine everything. In fact the job got so big that they had to build a two billion dollar new facility in Utah just for these activities. But even that was not enough, they enlisted private contractors. And large private security companies began taking over the spying business.
Seventy percent of America’s intelligence budget now flows to private contractors. Going by this year’s estimated budget of about $80 billion, that makes private intelligence a $56 billion-a-year industry.
Enter Edward Snowden. He was a contractor working for the giant defense and security firm Booz Allen Hamilton.

He revealed that through a program called PRISM the NSA had access to the metadata of all telephone conversations.  Moreover, they were monitoring (along with their British counterpart GCHQ) all of Internet traffic. They also had direct access points to Google, Yahoo, Facebook, Apple and Microsoft servers. Of course these companies denied the existence of such access but they acknowledge that they complied with requests of information from the NSA.

Of course, this is a meaningless denial since the NSA warrants are very broad, the rules and procedures are secret and these companies cannot discuss even the extent or nature of NSA requests.

I am pretty sure they have full blown TIA. Snowden stated that they only have access to metadata of telephone and email communications (where, when, who type of information) but I suspect he was being cautious not to reveal all he knows at once. With the kind of access described in this Power Point presentation, I don't see how they would just limit themselves to metadata.

In fact, there was a recent example of the kind of access we are talking about. If you remember, the FBI sort of acknowledged that they had access to previous phone conversations between Boston marathon bomber Tsarnaev and his wife. Since they were not persons of interests at the time, it meant that they could go back and find past communications.

Having said all that and perhaps weaken your trust in the inherent goodness and decency of the national security state, I want to highlight a couple of intriguing points about Snowden.

His timing coincided with the US visit of Chinese President Xi Jinping. One of the most important topic on Obama's agenda was the Chinese hacking. He even said that he had blunt talks with Xi. Within days, Snowden revealed (from Hong Kong where he was holed up) that the US government routinely engaged in similar hacking activities.
Within hours of news breaking that the US had filed charges against Snowden, the South China Morning Post reported that the whistleblower had handed over a series of documents to the paper detailing how the US had targeted Chinese phone companies as part of a widespread attempt to get its hands on a mass of data.
Clearly, this is a major embarrassment for the US government whose motto is "Do As We Say Not As We Do."
 All over the country, a magic switch went on. Thousands of writers and editors who hadn’t dared touch the Snowden story on Tuesday couldn’t get enough of it on Wednesday.
“The U.S. Has Attacked Chinese Networks for 15 Years,” said a headline in The Yangtze Daily. “Snowden Leaks Information About Prism to Reveal the Hypocrisy of the U.S. Government,” added The Wuhan Evening News. 
China Daily quoted a Chinese expert on American affairs saying, “For months, Washington has been accusing China of cyberespionage, but it turns out the biggest threat to the pursuit of individual freedom and privacy in the U.S. is the unbridled power of the government.”      
Another intriguing point is the incomplete extradition request sent to Hong Kong authorities. The people who put together dossiers like these do not make mistakes. My guess is that the State Department was fearful of further revelations in case he was blocked in Hong Kong and they had tp go through a lengthy extradition process. No one knows for sure how many secret files Snowden took from the NSA computers (he has been travelling with four laptops) and the way he intervened in the Obama Xi debate must have given them pause.

I never understood why he went to Hong Kong until he gave this important trump card to China. If it was done on purpose this was an astute move.

Once he left Hong Kong, Snowden decided to fly out to Moscow, en route to Ecuador. When the US asked Russian authorities to prevent him from leaving the country they flatly refused that request. Russia is about one of the few countries in the world to be able to thumb their noses to the US in such a situation. Another good move on Snowden's part.

As for his asylum request to Ecuador, the most significant part of it is the fact that it was arranged by Wikileaks. The message this conveys is that his secrets could be shared with the organization and even if he is intercepted and "rendered" back home, the genie will be let out of the bottle.

These are all excellent moves and shows wit and knowledge on the part of Ed Snowden.

If he has the goods, that is documents proving the extraordinary overreach of the NSA and the US intelligence community, he might one day be known as the guy who brought the National Security State to its knees.

18 June 2013

Standing Man in Occupy Istanbul

As you know, the protests that started out as a minor display of environmental discontent turned into an epic yet peaceful confrontation with the authorities. Last week, I wrote that this was something completely new in Turkey and it signaled the birth of a civil society.

I also suggested that the Prime Minister was likely to separate the environmental element of the protest from the political discontent and act generously regarding the former. And he would use fiery rhetoric to whip up more support from his base.

He did both but he was much less generous about the environmental demands than I thought and his rhetoric to his constituency was much more belligerent and polarizing.

When he ordered the police to take back the Square there were skirmishes all around the area. Initially, I was dismayed that the demonstrators abandoned their non-violent civil disobedience and began confronting the riot police. But it quickly became clear that the groups that responded in kind belonged to some traditional left wing organizations and had little to do with the original demonstrators.

Those young people were using a different tactic. They were moving to an area and waiting for the police to attack them. Then, instead of standing there and taking a beating, they were quickly dispersing only to pop up somewhere else. It was a cat-and-mouse game that really unnerved the riot police. Social media sites had cell phone clips of police officers really in tears begging the protesters to stop doing that.

A young man said that in the past, there were two kinds of resistance: active or passive. This is a new one, he said and we invented it. It is neither active (we are non-violent) nor passive (we refuse to be pepper sprayed silently). And we are the video game generation, our goal is not to win or quit when we loose. We will play for as long as we want.

Everyday they came up with a new expression of civil disobedience. Now that the Taksim Square is open to pedestrians, yesterday a young man stood in a corner and stayed there for eight hours. People quickly realized that he came up with a new way of communicating their anger.
His protest quickly captured the imagination of the protest movement. The hash tag "duranadam" ("standing man") dominated Turkish-language Twitter on Tuesday morning.
Then others started standing up in different areas of the Square. The original protester was a performance artist by the name of Erdem Gunduz. This is him in the center and behind him are the people who later joined his silent and immobile protest. They are looking at a large picture of Ataturk that is hanging from the Opera building in one corner of the Square.


Apparently, this unnerved the police and they detained ten people. According to social media, these detainees were charged with resisting police by not making a statement and by not moving. You can see how perversely funny this new mode of demonstration: try making those charges stick in a court of law.

This is what I meant when I suggested that these events looked like the birth of a civil society. These people did not need some kind of leader to tell them what to do. They got together spontaneously, organized themselves, quickly adopted an inclusionary and non-violent posture and they resisted traditional organized groups trying to take over the movement by re-introducing violent methods.

More importantly, their demands were not material benefits to be bargained down, as they were revendicating more freedom in a better society. And how they formulated these demands was as important as their content.

In contrast, Erdogan's response could not have been more traditional.

He copied to old state over society blueprint: He organized rallies in conservative neighborhoods, he bussed in his supporters, he called these young people terrorists and threatened to use the full power of the state against anyone and everyone who helped them.

In other words, we are the state and we are in charge and you the society should know your place and shut up when we tell you to.

Kenan Evren, the general who led the last coup in 1980, would have been proud.

It is indeed ironic that a party whose actions helped the emergence of a civil society is completely unequipped and unable to deal with that society.